Not that I can think of. That’s going to do it for today’s blog let me know what you think of it in the comments section below or on Facebook or Twitter @jimwyman10.
Oh…I guess you wanted something a little more…in depth. Fine. Well as you may remember (or not, because I certainly forgot there was an issue), Notre Dame just received their punishment for a cheating scandal from the 2012-13 seasons after an appeal they made back in 2016. That’s the judicial process for you. The punishment? Their 2012-13 seasons never happened. The NCAA vacated all 21 of their wins in those two seasons, which included an appearance in the BCS National Championship game after the 2012 season where they lost to Alabama. Allegedly what happened was a student athletic trainer gave improper benefits to 8 football players. More specifically, he did a significant amount of schoolwork for 2 players and gave impermissible aid to 6 others. So because an athletic trainer helped these kids cheat on their homework, the NCAA gets to say that their championship run didn’t happen which is just ridiculous. Now, based on a couple of articles I’ve read, we were not provided the names of the specific players involved in the cheating scandal, however it is noted that of the guys involved in the scandal, three of the eight players involved played while they should have been ineligible and of those three, one played in the National Championship.
Now, I’m more than willing to admit that I don’t have any perfect ideas for how to fix this, but there has to be a better way to go about things. Since the players involved had already moved on from the program prior to the NCAA’s investigation, it doesn’t really make sense for them to punish them since it won’t affect the program. But trying to tell the public that two seasons didn’t happen? Give me a break. College football fans aren’t stupid, unless they root for Purdue. It’s not like WWE where you can retcon certain things to fit the storylines you want to tell. This is college football where legacies and stats matter and fans don’t forget so easily. The 2012 season completely reinvigorated Notre Dame football and brought them back to relevance after years of being totally mediocre under Charlie Weis. You’re not going to make people forget so easily. So what punishment is there? Because I’m not trying to sit here and say there shouldn’t be some sort of retribution. Cheating on your schoolwork isn’t fair to the rest of the students/athletes that put in the work to get their education. But punishing the university isn’t fair to the players who were abiding by the rules by trying to devalue their efforts and it’s not fair to the coaches whose legacies and reputations could be tarnished because some guys decided to take shortcuts. The punishments should only apply to the people involved. But you can’t exactly retroactively fine these guys because they weren’t paid by the university in the first place. I do have one idea for a punishment, though.
Revoke their degree. I know it sounds harsh and may not even be do-able, as I don’t know how this stuff works with degrees (or anything for that matter, since a miscommunication with my adviser is likely going to result in me graduating later than expected), but hear me out. They didn’t do the work themselves, so the credits that they had towards graduation in which these classes were cheated in should be taken away. They’d have to retake the courses at a community college because from what I understand about cheating, that’s pretty much going to get you kicked out of college. So I’d totally get it if they wanted to say “you’re not welcome back here.” A retroactive expulsion, if you will. Now of course, this is imperfect. It’s entirely possible that the players involved in the cheating scandal declared early for the NFL Draft and wouldn’t have their degree anyway. The credits could still be taken away, but I really don’t have an answer to the issue of players that didn’t have their degree anyway. You could probably just say they’re not welcome at the school anymore, which could be huge for some guys as college pride is still a big thing, especially at a university like Notre Dame. At least with this, only the offenders are punished and not the entire program.
It just sucks to see the NCAA take away wins because not only is it not a real punishment because non-Purdue college football fans aren’t stupid. But also because it tarnishes legacies. If Notre Dame head coach Brian Kelly were to be up for induction into the college football Hall of Fame, they wouldn’t be allowed to include the 2012 run as part of his credentials because some dumb kids decided they’d cheat and they just got caught too late. Like how is that fair to anyone? And don’t even get me started on the whole vacating awards because Reggie Bush won the 2005 Heisman Trophy and there’s nothing you can do or say to convince me otherwise. Yet the NCAA vacated it because he took some money to help his family that was living in poverty. The NCAA is just deciding to let these things happen without trying to come up with a better solution and it’s really frustrating to me that we’ve been dealing with these issues for so long and they still haven’t been able to come up with anything. Sure my revocation of degrees isn’t perfect, but I think it at least gives a little more fairness to the people who didn’t have anything to do with the situation.
That’s going to do it for today’s blog. Happy Valentine’s Day, I’m going to spend mine with my true love, Riley Reid. That’s the life of a blogger for you. Let me know if you have any ideas about how to deal with the NCAA’s retroactive punishment issues in the comments section below or on Facebook or Twitter @jimwyman10. I also accept valentines. It gets lonely in my creepy poorly-lit apartment.