Holy shit, trades actually happened at the NFL Trade Deadline. Midseason trades typically don’t happen in the NFL because of the learning curve to switching systems midseason that is usually required. But this year some teams have chosen to be active this past week or so in the attempt to bolster their roster. A look at the major trades that took place:
Buffalo Bills trade DT Marcell Dareus to the Jacksonville Jaguars for a 2018 6th Round Pick
That’s it? That’s all the Jaguars had to give up to acquire a stud defensive tackle? Sure Dareus may come with some baggage, but he’s one of the best interior defensive linemen in the NFL. He seems to be worth much more than a 6th rounder. For Jacksonville, they acquire an excellent run stuffer that will help a unit that ranks 31st against the run. And yes I am aware this trade took place days ago and not during today’s Trade Deadline. But Dareus is a good enough player and the timing is close enough that I’m including it.
Houston Texans trade OT Duane Brown to the Seattle Seahawks for CB Jeremy Lane, a 2018 5th Round Pick, and a 2019 2nd Round Pick
I thought the Seahawks gave up a little much for Brown here (I thought the trade would’ve been fair without the 2nd rounder), but the need was so great that I don’t fault them for it. In fact, there were reports saying that the Seahawks were so desperate for a left tackle, they were willing to trade superstar TE Jimmy Graham for one. They receive stud Texans tackle Duane Brown, who has had his issues with the Houston organization this season. Brown had been holding out for most of the season before playing his first game this past Sunday (against the Seahawks, no less). Brown is a former All Pro and immediately becomes the best lineman on this Seahawks roster, even if he’s only half the player he was a few years ago. Jeremy Lane is by no means a star corner, but he can impact the game and I think the Texans will be happy to have him.
New England Patriots trade QB Jimmy Garoppolo to the San Francisco 49ers for a 2018 2nd Round Pick
This was the most shocking trade to me. I figured that the reason the Patriots acquired so much ammunition in the offseason was because they felt that Tom Brady’s career was on its last legs and they wanted to set him up for one final run. This trade of Garoppolo tells me that they are confident that he has a few more great years left in him (he has given them no reason to believe otherwise, as he leads the NFL in passing by almost 400 yards). I have no issue with the compensation, as a lot of other Pats fans do. The 49ers are currently 0-8 and Garoppolo isn’t going to magically turn them around, so this second round pick will likely come at around pick #33 or #34, which is basically a first round pick. There were reports that the Browns offered the Patriots the 12th overall pick in last year’s draft for Jimmy G, which they traded to the Texans to draft Deshaun Watson when New England turned them down, so one must wonder if the Patriots got all they could for the fourth year pro. The Patriots now only have Tom Brady on the roster at quarterback and will likely sign the newly-released Brian Hoyer, who had backed up Brady for the first three years of his career. Or maybe even another former 49ers signal caller…
Miami Dolphins trade RB Jay Ajayi to the Philadelphia Eagles for a 2018 4th Round Pick
This came as a shock to me because at no point were there any whispers that Ajayi was on the block or that the Eagles were searching for a runningback. Ajayi is having a down year from his breakout 2016 season, but that could be due in large part to the bad quarterback situation in Miami allowing defenses to stack the box against the run, much like what happened with Todd Gurley last season. The Eagles already have options at runningback, as LeGarrette Blount, Corey Clement, and Wendell Smallwood have been a part of a rotation that is 4th in the NFL in rushing. Also, really? Just a 4th round pick? Ajayi ran for 200 yards on 3 separate occasions last season and finished with over 1200 yards. I read somewhere (I think it was reported by Jeff Darlington) that the Dolphins were concerned about Ajayi’s long-term knee health stemming from an injury he suffered in college and that was why they sent him to Philly. That might also explain the lower draft pick because Philly may also have had that concern. We may learn more in the coming days.
Carolina Panthers trade WR Kelvin Benjamin to the Buffalo Bills for a 2018 3rd Round Pick and a 2018 7th Round Pick
Like Ajayi, this trade also came as a surprise to me, as I didn’t think Benjamin was on the market, though it didn’t surprise me that the Bills were searching for a receiver. Buffalo receivers are dead last in the NFL in yards and catches this season and Benjamin is a big-bodied receiver with loads of potential. This move surprises me from Carolina’s standpoint because not only do they now have limited options at receiver, but the compensation I felt was subpar for the former first rounder. Benjamin has been solid (albeit inconsistent) since entering the league in the star-studded 2014 receiver class. I think the Panthers could’ve gotten more for him, maybe even the extra first rounder the Bills acquired from the Chiefs in the 2017 NFL Draft. But nonetheless, Benjamin adds a whole other dimension to this Bills offense that has been lacking, yet finds themselves in the thick of a playoff hunt.
Cincinnati Bengals don’t trade QB AJ McCarron to the Cleveland Browns
The Bengals and Browns agreed on a trade for QB AJ McCarron at 3:55 pm (deadline is at 4) but the Browns did not relay their half of the agreement until after the deadline, so McCarron is staying in Cincinnati. Classic Browns. Who knows what they would have given the Bengals for the former Alabama signal caller, but in the past the Bengals had reported that they were looking for as high as a first round pick for him. The Browns have 2 first rounders and 3 second rounders in the 2018 draft. We may never know what the compensation would have been. Also, curious that these two arch rivals would be doing business together over a quarterback.
Those are my thoughts on the trades that took place today. Did any of these moves surprise you? Let me know in the comments section below or on Facebook or Twitter @jimwyman10.